Platforms
- PCMar 20, 20247.1playscore6.632 Critics7.81.75K Players
- PlayStation 5Mar 20, 20247.2playscore6.657 Critics8.02.35K Players
- Xbox Series X|SMar 20, 20247.2playscore6.524 Critics8.3200 Players
109 critic reviews · 2 community reviews across all platforms
Critic Reviews
- Alone in the Dark is a game that gets 60% right, and the rest is a mixture of poor or frustrating gameplay mechanics. The story is interesting and takes the player to some fascinating places as its focus on the mind and dream world become heavier the further the story progresses; a plot that feels more psychological horror than the typical survival horror game experience.
Dominic Sheard · May 13, 2024 Reviewed on PCRead full review - In one sense, it feels strange to even think Pieces Interactive had big shoes to fill with this series' legacy. Given what's come before, did it really? And yet, even when considering the last two flops over a two-decade span, there's still something about Alone in the Dark emblazoned on a title screen that carries a sense of revered history. In that respect, perhaps this reboot's best accomplishment is in honoring that spirit through its inventive world. It's also fair to emphasize knocks against its survival-horror design, some puzzle-solving, and so on; it certainly won't be considered a trendsetter like the 1992 classic. Still, the amount of goodwill wedded to its brighter qualities makes for something that dawdles the line between unfortunately-flawed and impressively-enticing.
Lee Mehr · Apr 22, 2024 Reviewed on Series X|SRead full review - Alone in the Dark (2024) developers decided to run away and jump into the rich Survival Horror genre, without having any trump cards at the ready. That’s exactly what the authors of the new Alone in the Dark decided to do. The mystical plot of evil in the Louisiana swamps quickly turns into a disjointed kaleidoscope, where characters and any semblance of integrity are lost. The game system turned out to be obscenely poor: four types of weapons, five types of enemies, two types of puzzles! This thing can only be recommended to researchers of the genre, and other players do not even need to know about the existence of Alone in the Dark.
Brau3er · Apr 12, 2024 Reviewed on PCRead full review - Despite all that, this new Alone in the Dark is certainly a worthy inheritor of the series’ legacy. While it doesn’t innovate a genre like the original, nor does it experiment with physics and open world design like 2008’s AitD: Inferno did, it’s clearly a labor of love by people with a reverence for the source material. Where it impresses most is its unwillingness to let fealty to the original narrative limit its aspirations. Yes, all of the classic beats are here for those who can recall them, but the way it takes that material and spins it into a captivating tale of an ancient evil with its tendrils sunk deep into the characters’ pasts is a sight to behold.
Jason Ricardo · Apr 08, 2024 Reviewed on Series X|SRead full review - Alone in the Dark checks all the boxes when it comes to gameplay elements you would expect in a modern survival horror, but these seem to be stuck in the past. It feels like a project made with passion but enough budget to hit the AAA expectations. The archaic mechanics do not involve a pleasant nostalgia, rather make the entire game feel outdated. Overall, it is not a bad game, but it does not have enough oomph to make it compete with the best games out there, let alone reconquer the throne of the genre. With a hefty discount it can become an interesting choice for the fans of the genre, a period that should also give time to the developers to fix the bugs that are still present.
Cosmin Vasile · Mar 26, 2024 Reviewed on PS5Read full review - Alone in the Dark is a surprisingly competent effort that looks back at its own legacy more than towards where the genre has gone. There's less of a focus on combat and survival with the mystery of Derceto taking up the majority of my attention. The performances from Comer and Harbour add some gravitas to a tale that can occasionally stray into theatrics but there's a solid sense of atmosphere and good foundation for whatever comes next. I do wonder about longevity with the two campaigns sadly mirroring one another. Combat, whilst not front and centre, does seem to lack menace. I'd still recommend it, for anyone curious.
Mike · Mar 25, 2024 Reviewed on PS5Read full review - Alone in the Dark is a hauntingly atmospheric experience with clever puzzles and a decent narrative. However, frustrating combat mechanics and occasional technical hiccups prevent it from being a truly great game. The short campaign length might leave some players wanting more, but the Director’s Commentary Mode offers a valuable bonus for horror enthusiasts. The Vintage Horror Filter adds a nice touch of customization, but it’s not essential for everyone. Ultimately, Alone in the Dark is a decent return to form for the franchise. It’s worth checking out for fans of the genre and those seeking a good dose of Southern Gothic horror, just be prepared for a few stumbles along the way.
Kimberly Mae Go · Mar 24, 2024 Reviewed on PS5Read full review - Alone in the Dark is looking to be the best remake we've had in a while; between the excellent voice acting and the detail in design and lore, there's never a dull moment while you're out solving this mystery.
Jay Claassen · Mar 23, 2024 Reviewed on PCRead full review - While true fans of the franchise might get a kick out of seeing a new take on an old story, Alone in the Dark is a tonal and functional mess that frustrates more than it entertains.
Steve Wright · Mar 20, 2024 Reviewed on Series X|SRead full review - Alone in the Dark has fumbled once again, with this reimagining circling the drain to a pit of mediocrity. Though the game itself and the environments can be beautiful, it doesn’t take advantage of its star-studded cast nor does it tell a story that is remotely sensical or engaging. Always offering just the bare minimum of staples for the survival horror genre and nothing more, it’s sad to see the grand daddy of the genre be a shell of its former self. Maybe Alone in the Dark should remain exactly like its namesake.
Charlie Kelly · Mar 20, 2024 Reviewed on PCRead full review
Loading reviews
Community Reviews
- Reviewed on PS5
- Rated on PC
About the game
Trailers & Screenshots:
Psychological Horror meets Southern Gothic in this reimagination of the classic survival horror game, Alone in the Dark This love letter to the ground-breaking original lets you experience a haunting story through the eyes of one of two protagonists. Play as either Edward Carnby or Emily Hartwood and explore your environments, fight monsters, solve puzzles and uncover the uneasy truth of Derceto Manor… Deep in the 1920’s south, Emily Hartwood’s uncle has gone missing. Together with private investigator Edward Carnby, she embarks on a journey to Derceto Manor, a home for the mentally ill where something is lurking. You’ll encounter strange residents, nightmarish realms, dangerous monsters and ultimately uncover a plot of rising evil. At the intersection of reality, mystery, and insanity, an adventure waits that will challenge your core beliefs. Who can you trust, what will you believe, and what will you do next?
Developer: Pieces Interactive